This method is also great for the environment because you reuse containers that you would usually just throw in the garbage. The containers act like little greenhouses where the seeds will germinate at their own pace when they are ready, much like in nature. It's great because you can take your time and work on sowing your containers all through the winter. But be careful because it's so easy that you end up with way more containers than you realize; and then when your seedlings are ready to be planted, you'll find that you don't have nearly enough space in your garden to plant them all. It's a good problem to have!
When I used to start my seeds indoors, I estimate my success rate was only about 25-50% of the seeds I sowed would germinate and survive being transplanted into the garden. Now with winter sowing, I estimate my success rate is about 75-100%!! It's crazy! Here is a picture of the containers that are currently sitting out by my deck...
For your flats, you can use any type of plastic container with a lid as long as the lid is clear and closes tightly. I have heard from other winter sowers that they prefer 2 liter bottles or milk jugs, I prefer the type of take out container you get a salad or sandwich in from a restaurant.
Experiment with different types of containers and see what you prefer. The shape and size of the container doesn't matter, but it must be deep enough to allow for 2-3 inches of dirt and at least a few inches of space between the dirt and the lid to allow room for the seedlings to grow. (Updated Jan-09-2011 - See my post about winter sowing containers for more information)
Here are the steps to get you started with winter sowing...
- Clean the container well and then poke holes in the bottom and top of the container. Heating a knife and melting the holes makes this task easier. (Use an old knife and not a good one because it will turn black over time and have plastic residue on it.) You don't want to poke too many holes, only enough for drainage but not so many that the water will run right through and allow the soil to dry out quickly. (note: If you're using a tall narrow container like a 2lt bottle or milk jug, you'll need to cut the container in half as well.)
- Add your potting soil to the container and sow the seeds like you normally would, according to the directions on the packet. I use the same type of potting soil in my winter sowing containers that I use when starting seeds indoors. I buy the seed starting soil mix that is specifically made for starting seeds. It's a little more expensive than other soil mixes. You could probably find a recipe online to mix your own seed starting mix and possibly save some money. Either way, you absolutely want to use fresh, sterile soil when starting any seeds; and never, never use soil from your garden in any of your containers.
- Mark the container. There are a few ways to do this. I have heard some people use masking or duct tape to label their containers. If you do this, make sure to put the tape on the bottom of the container or it will fade by Spring (even with permanent marker). I like to cut up old vinyl mini blinds and write on them with pencil and push the marker into the soil, these won't fade.
- Water them well. I like to use the sprayer in my kitchen sink and saturate the soil and let the excess water drain out.
- Put the lid on the container and put it outside in a protected spot that gets only morning sun. This part is crucial! Whatever you do, do not put them in full sun! This will just bake the seeds and they will not germinate. (I made this mistake with some of mine the first year). When I say morning sun I mean a location where they will be in the sun only until about 11am, and then they are in shade for the rest of the day. Remember that the sun changes as we move into Spring so check regularly to make sure the spot you chose in February doesn't suddenly become a full sun location in March or April. Also be careful to protect them from strong winds so they won't blow away.
- Now forget about them until about mid to late March.
- Once the weather starts to warm up and is consistantly above freezing during the days, check your containers regularly for any signs of growth. Cold weather plants will start to germinate first, things like broccoli, lettuce, spinach and spring blooming perennials.
- The only maintenance you have to do at this point is to make sure they stay out of the full sun and make sure the soil doesn't dry out. As they start to grow, I like to take the lids off during the day and put them in the sun (if they are full sun plants). Then I will cover them back up in the evening before it gets dark. This is optional though, you don't have to do this.
- Once the seedlings get tall enough where they are touching the top of the inside of the container, it's time to remove the lids for good. Once you remove the lids, you can move them into the full sun (if they are full sun plants). Check them at least once a day to make sure the soil hasn't dried out. They can dry out pretty quickly once you take the lids off. Also keep an eye on the weather report. If there is a chance of frost, cover the containers with a sheet or blanket over night.
- That's it, at this point the hard part is over!
So, when can you plant them into your garden? Well, for most plants you will need to wait until after the last frost date to be safe. Cold weather plants can be planted much earlier however. Here in Minnesota, we are in Zone4. That means that cold weather plants (which can handle frost exposure) can be planted as early as mid to late April. Our average last frost date is about May 15th so you'll need to wait to plant most of your seedlings until after the last frost. Every year is different though so keep an eye on the weather report.
Keep in mind that not all seeds will do well if you sow them very early in the winter (December-January). Start your cold weather veggies and any plants that are self sowing or require cold stratification first. Then, as you move in to late winter (February-March), start your warm weather plants like tomatoes, beans and peppers. I wait until late March into April before I start my tropical seeds and succulents. As I sow my seeds this year, I will share my list and more pictures.
Now, get busy collecting and preparing those containers and get some sowing done! Have fun and good luck! Feel free to ask me any questions you may have.
Pin It
I was so excited to read this post! Wish I would've read the part about using old knives yesterday! I like your idea about using the cut up blinds here. If the containers get covered with snow should I just leave them alone? I am still a bit uncertain as to which seeds are okay to start with this method. I tried sorting my seeds out to figure which ones I can winter sow. How about Datura seeds? Can I do those? Is it safe to assume that all perennials can be winter sown? Thanks again for your excellent post. You are a great writer!
ReplyDeleteHi Julie,
ReplyDeleteThanks, I'm glad you like my post!
Yes, it's fine if the containers get covered by snow.
As for which seeds to use, check the package. If they say anything about "self sowing", "direct sow outside in the fall", "direct sow outside in early spring", "cold stratification"... keywords like this are good indicators of seeds that will be good for winter sowing. Not all packets will say this though so if you're unsure, you can always try winter sowing 1/2 of them and see how well they do. I think you'd be safe in your assumption about perennial seeds. Datura seeds would work well, I had great success with those. The only seeds I have tried that didn't do well when I started them this early were beans and peas. Last year I waited to start those in winter sowing containers until late March and they did great!
That's a great post Amy; it was very informative and well-composed. Now I understand why we've saved a pile of stuff that normally would go in the recycling or garbage!
ReplyDeleteI thought of a couple questions.
ReplyDelete1. The first question has to do with timing. I'm the vegetable-garden-guy part of our gardening team. I'd like to try starting some vegetables from seed that I would normally buy as seedlings. Specifically, I'd like to try tomatos, broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage, and a variety of peppers. I'd be nervous using the winter sowing technique with the tomatoes and peppers, since they pretty sensitive to cold weather and frost. The others are pretty tough. Do you have a timeline you'd suggest?
2. My second question has to do with containers. I have lots and lots of seed starter trays that have a clear plastic top. Can I use these, or do I have to group-plant them all in one container. I'm thinking it will make transplanting easier if each seed is planted separately, but maybe this technique requires them to be planted together to achieve some 'thermal mass'. What do you think?
Thanks again for the original post. Any follow-up help would be greatly appreciated.
Amy~
ReplyDeleteI have a question about Coleus seeds. I'm pretty sure they are too sensitive for winter sowing so how do you recommend I start them? Indoors in a sunny window? Outdoors after last frost? My plan is to have them in pots for the summer and them I'll take cuttings for next year. Thanks again for your excellent guidance!
Hi Paul,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your nice comments. I'm glad you could think of some questions to ask...
1. You can start both tomatoes and peppers with this method. They will both do fine, but if you want to be safe, you can try some of them with this method and the rest with your usual method and see what you like best. As you said, the broccoli, cauliflower and cabbage will do great and will be the first ones you start to see growing. As for a timing, you can start them any time now. The seeds are programmed to know when it is safe for them to germinate. :-) I have tomatoes and peppers reseed themselves in my garden every year. Any seed that self sows does great with this method.
2. I would not recommend using those little cells with this method because they will dry out way too fast. You need at least a couple of inches of dirt in a container so it will hold moisture and retain healthy seed growth. You could use those flats though if you can remove the cells and figure out a way to secure the top so it won't blow away... and don't forget to make holes in the top and bottom.
Good luck and let me know how it goes for you!!
Amy
Hi Julie,
ReplyDeleteColeus are very easy to start in a sunny window in your house. They don't require any special seedling care and won't become leggy inside. You can also use the winter sowing method in early spring (April/May) or sow them directly into your pot outside in May. They are very easy to grow from seed.
Amy
Hi Amy:
ReplyDeleteI've been starting seeds in-doors for a couple years now using an aquarium. This method is something I would love to try with vegetables. I started my Tomatoes and Peppers last week in-doors and since I'm running out of room and lighting I think this would be a great experiment for me to try with the remainder of my vegetable seeds since the garden keeps getting bigger and bigger. I still have to plant my beans and peas, zucchini, lettuce, pumpkin and so and and so forth. I have been a little leery with the warm and now cold weather we are having here in Minnesota. Would it be too late for me to try this method? Also, I have some Joe Pye Weed and Rosemary that I have been trying to winter sow for the last 3 weeks with this method. I don't see anything yet is this normal?
Hi FranksGreenGirl!
ReplyDeleteI know what you mean about running out of room quickly when you start your seeds indoors. I am so happy that I discovered winter sowing! For the last few years, I have been starting seeds indoors as well as winter sowing. This year, I jumped in with both feet and am winter sowing all of my seeds...none inside for me this year!
No, it's definitely not too late for you to start winter sowing your veggies. In fact, I just started all of my beans, peas and a few peppers last weekend. I haven't even started my annuals yet, I'll be starting on those this weekend and will continue well into April! I understand the concern to start your veggies this way when we're still experiencing freezing and thawing. It sounds funny, but the seeds are kinda programmed to know when it's safe to start growing. Once you start to see sprouts, keep the lids on your containers overnight. If we're going to have a really cold night, you can cover the containers with a blanket or move them into the garage if you want. Last year I had all my lids off and everything was growing great, then in May we had a night where we were supposed to get frost. The seedlings were too tall to put the lids back on, so I covered them with a blanket and they were fine (sure enough, the blanket was covered with frost the next morning).
Don't worry about the seeds you haven't seen growing yet, I haven't seen growth in most of my containers yet either. With this warm Spring we've been having, I suspect you will start to see growth soon. Keep me posted on your progress and good luck!
Amy
By the way, here is a link to my current winter sowing status report... Winter Sowing status report #4. There are links at the bottom to my previous status reports.
ReplyDeleteAmy - ready to try the winter sowing! My question is, how many seed do I put into one of the containers? My containers are 6 x 6. Think I will give the ice cream buckets a try as well. Thoughts? Thanks! Theresa
ReplyDeleteHi Theresa! Glad to hear you're going to try winter sowing, how exciting! I usually try to space my seeds about an inch apart in the containers. Sometimes I squeeze them in closer if I have a few seeds left over. Take a look at the second picture on this blog post of mine, you'll see the spacing of the peas I sowed in one of my containers... WS Status Report #2. You don't have to get too worried about spacing since the seedlings won't live in the containers for too long. Good luck!!
ReplyDeleteAmy
Great post Amy.Thanks for your useful tips on winter sowing.The idea looks great. I am planning to try it out. Hope i would succeed in it.
ReplyDeleteGreat! Good luck.
DeleteYou have no idea how excited I am that I found your blog posts on winter sowing. I bought seeds today and will start my "sowing" project this week.
ReplyDeleteYeah!! Good luck and feel free to ask my any questions.
DeleteAmy
So, I have a couple of silly questions! I apologize for their ridiculousness--I'm originally a city girl, and my gardening attempts have not gone well, but I really would like to get growing!
ReplyDelete1) Would "afternoon" as opposed to morning sun be ok, as long as it isn't full sun? Our house doesn't really get much direct morning sun (hill, forest, etc.), but there is some good afternoon light.
2) At the end of the original post, there's a suggestion to cover the trays with a blanket in the event of frost overnight. But, temps are going to be below freezing most nights at this time of year. Would you just tuck them in at night every night, or is this method really meant for later in winter, like March, when you originally posted this?
Thanks so much!
Hi, great questions (and totally not ridiculous)!
Delete1) Yes, as long as you keep them out of the intense afternoon sun. You won't have to worry about this too much until it starts to get warmer.
2) You don't have to worry about this until after the seeds have sprouted, and you've taken the tops off of the containers. If you can't get the tops back on because the seedlings are too tall, then you'll need to protect them from frost. After the seeds have sprouted, if there's going to be freezing temps, you might also think about covering non-hardy seedling containers even if the lids are on. I've lost a few marigolds and zinnia seedlings to freezing temps in April.
Don't worry too much, just think of it as an experiment. Next year, you'll know what modifications to make to your containers and location...etc.
Hopefully you'll give it a try, I would love to hear how it goes for you!
Amy
P.S. I'm a city girl too. :-)
This will be my first time winter sowing as I had never heard of it before. My tomatoes actually do it on their own in my garden, as I've had quite a few volunteers the last couple years, so I guess I have been doing it without knowing it. I am looking forward to trying it here in southwest Ohio.
ReplyDeleteGreat, glad to hear you're going to give it a try. Good luck!
DeleteI am an avid gardener and just love to grow veggies. We supplement our food bill by growing as much as possible. Having moved from our house to a flat with a garden has it`s problems but we always had too much before. In the summer we had so much that we used to give to all the neighbours. The trouble was that even they could not use the quick enough. Now is still OK as we have just enough ground to supply our own needs.I have just prepared the ground and was fortunate to be able to dig in a lot of horse manure from my daughters farm.In South Africa it is quite difficult to get seedlings so I am using your method to get them going.
ReplyDeleteGreat, hope it works well for you! Good luck with your new garden.
DeleteAmy